Teaching Note 5

The Structure of Industry

Summary

As described below, the impact of the five forces on profitability from Porter's model (prior page) can be summarized, as follows:

COMPETITIVE FORCE

WILL LOWER PROFITABILITY WILL RAISE PROFITABILITY
Ease of Entry Easy to Enter if there is: Difficult to Enter if there is:

Common technology

Brand switching difficult

Access to distribution channels

Proprietary know-how

Restricted distribution channels

High scale threshold

Little brand franchise

Ease of Exit Difficult to Exit if there is: Easy to Exit if there is:

Specialized assets (High exit costs)

Salable assets

Interrelated businesses

Independent business

Power of Suppliers Suppliers Powerful if: Suppliers Weak if:

Credible forward integration threat by suppliers

Many competitive suppliers

Suppliers concentrated

Purchase commodity products

Significant cost to switch suppliers

Credible backward integration threat by purchasers

Customers Powerful

Concentrated purchasers or Customers Weak

Power of Buyers   

 

Buyers Powerful if: Buyers Weak if:

Buyers concentrated

Buyers threaten forward integration

Buyers purchase significant proportion of output

Significant buyer switching costs

Buyers possess credible backward integration threat (threaten to buy producing firm)

Buyers fragmented (many, different)

Producers supply critical portions of buyers' input

Threat of Substitutes Substitution Easy if: Substitution Difficult if:

Low user switching costs

High user switching costs

Substitute producers profitable and aggressive

Substitute producers unprofitable & passive

Rivalry Many Competitors if: Few Competitors if:

Competitors equal size

Diverse competitor sizes

Slow demand growth

Industry leader

Excess capacity

Low fixed costs

Diversity of approach and historical background

Commonality of approach and historical background

Commodity products

Differentiated products

High fixed costs

Fast demand growth